A sportswriter's idea over dinner in 1926 filled Madison Square Garden the following March and has been sending kids from every borough into the ring each winter since. Read the list of champions and you are reading this whole section.
The idea came up at dinner. Late in 1926 Paul Gallico, sports editor at the New York Daily News, was eating with fellow editors when he suggested an amateur boxing tournament, open to anyone, to be called the New York Daily News Golden Gloves. The publisher, Captain Joseph Medill Patterson, approved the name and the sponsorship on the spot.
There was a practical reason. Winter was a dead season for the sports pages. A tournament that ran for weeks, with heats and favorites and neighborhood rivalries, would give the paper something to write about every day and sell copies while it did.
The first winter
Boxing in New York had a bad name in those years. Fights were mostly local, and gambling and fixed bouts were common. Chicago had run a Golden Gloves tournament for one year, in 1922, before it was legislated out of existence in Illinois over exactly those problems.
Gallico advertised the new tournament in his own column. Around 1,200 entries came in, enough that he cut the application period short. He called in help: Al Copland, a fellow newsman who ran the paper's Silver Skates, and Dr. Thomas DeNaouley, who handled the physicals. The plan had been to run the preliminary rounds at two local venues. Copland realized almost at once that two would never finish on time and added fifteen more.
Gallico rented Madison Square Garden for the finals on March 28, 1927. Almost 22,000 people came. Nearly 10,000 more were turned away.
New York and Chicago
The next year the tournament added stricter physicals, to cut down on early knockouts among the novices, and gave entrants free practice time at local gyms. Boxing was legal again in Illinois, and the Chicago Tribune's tournament, organized by its sports editor Arch Ward, had resumed. The champions of the two cities began meeting each other in an Intercity tournament that alternated between New York and Chicago and ran from 1928 to 1961. For decades it drew about 20,000 people a year.
In 1962 the national structure changed and a body now called the Golden Gloves of America took over the national tournament. New York remained one of its franchises and kept its own name, its own finals and its own reputation, regularly ranked with Chicago's as one of the two elite Golden Gloves titles in the country.
In 1995 the New York Golden Gloves opened to women for the first time.
The roll call
The best way to understand what the tournament has meant to the city is to read who won it. Almost every fighter in this wave of The Record passed through it.
Sugar Ray Robinson won the featherweight title in 1939 and the lightweight title in 1940. Floyd Patterson, out of the Bedford-Stuyvesant Boxing Association gym, won the middleweight title in 1952, the same year he won Olympic gold in Helsinki. In 1958 Emile Griffith won at 147 pounds and José Torres won at 160. Héctor Camacho, from East Harlem, won the first of his three New York titles in 1978, in the 112-pound sub-novice division. Riddick Bowe of Brownsville won four: the 178-pound novice title in 1985, the 178-pound open in 1986, and the super heavyweight open in 1987 and 1988, the year he went to the Olympics.
Those are the famous names. The tournament's real population is everyone else. Kids from the Police Athletic League centers, from church gyms and parks department gyms, sub-novices who lost in the first round and never fought again, open-class fighters with day jobs who won a title and went back to work on Monday. The weight classes run from 112 pounds to over 201.
The gloves themselves
The name was literal. Winners received small golden gloves, a charm rather than a trophy, the kind of thing that ends up on a chain or in a drawer at a parent's house. People who have one tend to know where it is.
If you walk into any amateur gym in the five boroughs after New Year's, someone will be counting the weeks to the Gloves. We hear it every winter too.
Almost 22,000 people came to the first finals. Nearly 10,000 more were turned away.
The Record is the editorial desk of Kings County. Drafted from tournament histories and fighter records. Corrections and additions: write to the editors.
Sources
- New York Golden Gloves (founding, Gallico, Patterson, 1927 finals, Intercity, 1995 women, weight classes): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Golden_Gloves
- Golden Gloves (Arch Ward, Intercity 1928–1961, national tournament from 1962): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Gloves
- Bill Farrell, Cradle of Champions: 80 Years of the New York Daily News Golden Gloves (Sports Publishing, 2007)
- Fighter titles: Sugar Ray Robinson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sugar_Ray_Robinson · Floyd Patterson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Floyd_Patterson · Emile Griffith https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emile_Griffith · José Torres https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Torres_(boxer) · Héctor Camacho https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H%C3%A9ctor_Camacho · Riddick Bowe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riddick_Bowe

